We Feed Raw vs Farmer’s Dog 2026 Comparison (Raw Diet Or Fresh Dog Food?)

We Feed Raw is great for dog owners who:

• Fully believe in the benefits of a raw diet.
• Can afford pet food that’s 100 percent meat.

The Farmer’s Dog is great for dog owners who:

• Have less of a budget for dog food
• Want cooked dog food without any artificial substances in it.
• Want to support a brand that’s more devoted to its sustainability commitments.

Pros

• Premium raw food that can improve the immune system, gut bacteria content, allergy resistance, oral health, and skin health.
• Comprehensive meal plans for optimal nutrition. 
• Bulk order option to gain a large discount and save on shipping.
• Minimal food wastage as recipes 100 percent of the animal, from meat to organs to bones. 

Cons

• High meat content means it’s more expensive. Can cost anywhere from $6-$10 per day.
• Keeps for a shorter time than fresh cooked food, lasting only 4 days in the fridge and 6 months in the freezer.

Quality Raw Meat

We Feed Raw only sources from farms that raise livestock in pasture and ensure that each animal is grass-finished (that is, only eats grass for every day of their lives). This guarantees that they will have been raised as naturally as possible. This leads to ideal nutrient compositions, with protein content averaging at 44 percent, fat at 33 percent, and minimal carb content at around 11-15 percent. This is about as close as you can get to the nutrient composition of dogs’ ancestral diets.

Large Selection of Meats

We Feed Raw’s recipe selection exclusively hinges on which protein you think would be best for your pet and fits within your budget. This includes not commonly seen types of meat, such as duck, lamb, and venison. Those on a budget can choose cheaper meats such as beef and chicken, but if you’ve got a bit more disposable income, you can splurge and spoil your pup with some lamb or venison.

Stringent Quality Control

Because the food they deliver is raw, We Feed Raw employs several effective measures to ensure that it is free of any harmful microorganisms and other health risks. This is especially important for meat that is notorious for spreading disease when uncooked, such as chicken and pork. One of the methods they use is called cold pressure, which makes use of a gentle press to rid the meat of bacteria and other pathogens [1]. This way you get all the benefits of raw meat without risking life-threatening disease.

Minimal Food Wastage

Since We Feed Raw deals exclusively in meat, they make it a point to be as economical as possible with their products. Their raw food diets makes use of the whole animal, from organs to bones. They sell bony parts like ribs for dogs to chew on, and they even include ground bone in their recipes to enrich them with calcium, protein, and other nutrients. 

Easy Storage

The majority of We Feed Raw’s products are flat patties, which makes storage very easy. This also makes bulk orders more appealing. Bulk orders have the added bonus of having a lower overall cost and carbon footprint. However, the boxes only come with 1-pound patties. For a medium-sized dog, this is enough food for one day. But if your dog is below or above average size, you’ll have to figure out how to portion for them yourself.

Pros

• Ingredients for the fresh food are 100 percent natural, certified humane, and undergo strict QA for maximum nutrition potential.
• Plans go as low as $2, with free shipping.
• Engages in several sustainability commitments.
• Bulk shipping option to reduce shipping emissions.

Cons

• Has a shorter shelf life than other brands because of freshness and lack of preservatives.
• Not as many customization options as other brands.

Natural Ingredients and Preparation Methods

The Farmer’s Dog prides itself on using only 100 percent natural and completely unaltered ingredients, as well as traditional cooking methods that use no artificial substances. Meals are only vacuum packed; absolute no usage of artificial preservatives at all. All of their proteins were raised without growth hormones and their vegetables are non-GMO. Each recipe is also grainless and gluten-free.

Recipes Adjust According to Activity and Weight

Their recipe customization interface adjusts according to your dog’s activity level and weight. Depending on your dog’s age, sex, and breed, these determine the content of your recipes and the final cost of your subscription. If your dog is fairly healthy, you can end up spending quite a bit lower than the average for services such as this. 

Perfect For Sensitive Stomachs

Since the recipes were made with ingredients that are as natural as possible, they have no artificial substances that could react unpredictably with sick or elderly dogs. When a dog has a sensitive stomach, you can expect some minor flatulence, stomachaches, and vomiting at best. But at worst, feeding them an artificial diet could make their condition deteriorate further. The likelihood of this happening goes to near zero with a purely natural diet.

Sustainable Processing Methods 

The Farmer’s Dog is one of the dog food subscription brands that put extra emphasis on sustainability. Every step of their production process follows stringent sustainability practices. All of their ingredients are sustainably sourced, rated by Certified Humane and the USDA. Their packaging is 100 percent recyclable/biodegradable, and they deliver directly to customers, cutting emission-heavy middlemen out of the equation. To shrink their carbon footprint even further, they offer bulk delivery as well.

Excellent Affordability

Plans often go as low as $2-3 for a healthy average-sized dog. Compared to the market average of $6-7, this is remarkably affordable. However, your dog does have to be relatively young, and be of reasonably good health for you to only need to pay this much. Most customers tend to pay somewhere between $4 to $6 accounting for things like allergies, fur health, and others.

We Feed Raw’s products mostly come in the form of patties. These patties are composed of thick strips of meat that offer superior texture to meat that’s been simply ground up. For dogs that prefer to chew off their own bits of meat, We Feed Raw also offers ribs and other bone-in cuts. Bone is nature’s oral chews, helping dogs clean their mouths by stimulating the salivary glands and exercising the jaws.

Unlike The Farmer’s Dog, however, We Feed Raw does include artificial supplements in your dog’s food, as well as natural ones such as fish oil, to bring it up to par with diets that incorporate fruits and vegetables. 

Choose We Feed Raw if…

You firmly believe that your dog stands to benefit by being fed a raw diet. The main point of feeding your dog raw is to preserve the nutrients lost during preparation and cooking, like what happens with commercial dog food. We Feed Raw is committed to be the prime source for such food, while protecting dogs from the diseases. Keep in mind that you will have to be patient when it comes to transitioning a dog to raw food diet, and dogs that have become used to raw foods may find it hard to consume anything else. If you trust We Feed Raw’s methods, and believe that a diet composed of 99 percent raw meat is best for your dog, then it could be the best fit for you.

True to its name, The Farmer’s Dog makes products that are overall fresh, natural—exactly what a farmer would give to their dog. The products are free of any grains so you’re sure that your dog won’t be getting any empty carbs. Instead, each meal has a generous amount of nutritious veggies whose taste dogs commonly find agreeable. The proteins are ground up coarsely for even cooking and light seasoning while preserving texture.

However, since the ingredients are virtually untampered, that means they can also include things that you may not find agreeable, such as animal byproducts. Taste is comparable to that of other brands.

Choose The Farmer’s Dog if…

You want a brand that focuses on being natural and simple more than anything else. If you subscribe to The Farmer’s Dog, you will be a part of the sustainability efforts undertaken by this platform.