Spot and Tango vs Ollie 2026 Comparison (Quality Kibbles & Fresh Dog Food Battle)

Spot and Tango is great for dog owners who:

• Want one of the best quality dog kibbles on the market
• Have dogs that need special diets.
• Are big believers in upcycling and food waste reduction.

Ollie is great for dog owners who:

• Want more options to save on costs.
• Want pet food that uses novel ingredients to make its nutrient profile richer.
• Would like to support a brand that donates to dog shelters.

Pros

• UnKibble, their special “fresh dry” recipe. UnKibble tastes better and is more nutritious than most kinds of kibble. 
• Topper plans let you order a small portion of food to mix in with regular dog food. 
• Makes liberal use of fruits and vegetables in their recipes for a more fleshed-out nutrient profile.
• Simple subscription plan tweaking interface on their website. 

Cons

• Currently, if you want to order both fresh food and UnKibble, you have to explicitly tell them so through Spot and Tango’s customer service. 
• Subpar customer service according to some online reviews.

UnKibble

UnKibble is one of the only dry dog foods on the market that is made with fresh ingredients. It’s superior to most types of kibble you can find these days, even better than oven-baked kibble. It’s no substitute to truly fresh food, but if you want one of the best brands of kibble out there, UnKibble is the way to go. It is also about as shelf-stable as conventional kibble.

Competitive Pricing

UnKibble plans start at around $4.70 for the average-sized dog. This is below the $5-6 mark that most fresh dog food services usually hover at, but can still be a bit steep if you think that dry food should be cheaper. Their fresh food is about average, costing $6-7 for the average dog. Topper plans can cut your costs down by more than half, however, so it’s a decent option to consider if you want to save. 

Comprehensive Health Considerations in Recipes

Spot and Tango is among the best in terms of health considerations. They offer an expansive list of dietary specifications, such as special diets for oral problems, digestion, diabetes, and allergies. You can even input specific health conditions yourself if they’re not included in the list. 

Wide Range of Ingredients

Spot and Tango has excellent ingredient variety, owing partly to their commitment to accounting for a wide array of health conditions and dietary needs, or even just for the picky eaters. Recipes use ingredients like apple cider vinegar, blueberries, organ meats, red quinoa, and others that you don’t commonly see in fresh dog food products. What’s more is that you can even choose to make your recipes gluten-free or grainless. 

Practices Upcycling

Spot and Tango is one o the few fresh dog food companies that also makes a point to make use of ingredients that were deemed less than presentable [1] for retail markets. This includes what’s known as “ugly produce”, or vegetables that look a bit malformed but are nonetheless completely edible. Upcycling is a big help to the global food supply chain as it eliminates food wastage.

Pros

• Fleshed out recipes’ nutrient profiles thanks to the inclusion of nutritious ingredients such as spinach and berries.

• Customers are able to specify any food sensitivity or allergy during customization.
  
• Oven-baked kibble. This kind of kibble is more wholesome than the usual dried kibble.

• Customers can order partial portions or mixed portions of fresh food and dry food to save on costs. 

Cons 

• Customization doesn’t include consideration for weight loss, organ health, etc.
• Still a bit expensive despite savings options.

Plenty of Options to Save

Ollie offers several options to reduce costs, such as partial and mixed ordering. You can order partial portions in increments of 25 percent of your dog’s recommended daily caloric intake Shipping is also free.

Baked Kibble

Ollie’s dry food is slowly oven-baked, unlike most commercially available kibble that is blasted by heat under pressure and then dried. This more careful style of cooking makes Ollie’s kibble much fresher, tastier, and more nutritious.

Rich Recipes

Their recipes are intended to be a replacement for supplements, or at least be nutritious enough to reduce the need for them. That’s why they’re enhanced with superfoods such such as chia seeds and cod liver oil. These special ingredients make their recipes’ nutrient profiles much richer than most. 

Enhances Appetites

Ollie is perfect for making mealtimes much more interesting. Mix even just a small portion into the everyday food that a dog has gotten used to, and it’ll turn into a whole new gastronomic experience for them. Great for dogs who have started to snub their doggy bowls and even started to lose weight.

Supports Rescue Organizations

Ollie is a true friend to rescues, donating 1 percent of all of their income to pet shelters throughout the USA. In addition to this, they also donate their dog food to these dogs in need.

Spot and Tango offers rather standard fresh meals—not remarkable, but not bad either. They look like what you might expect from subscription-based services like this: ground meat and chopped vegetables. UnKibble looks like if you rolled fresh food into balls and baked them. But what really makes Spot and Tango stand out are the expansive considerations in every meal plan for health conditions and special diets. Its kibble is also far superior to that offered by most other subscription services and commercial brands. 

Choose Spot and Tango If…

Your dog prefers kibble, or needs a special diet for things like stamina or better bone health. Spot and Tango UnKibble is simply superior even to Ollie’s carefully made baked kibble. Recipes aren’t designed to be nutrient-complete like Ollie’s, but the specialization can make up for it if your dog’s food has to be a more specialized diet. Plus points if you think that food wastage is a truly pressing issue.

By all accounts, Ollie dog food seems to be a less appealing version of Spot and Tango. They both let you specify what health conditions need to come into consideration for your recipes. But Spot and Tango also lets you specify if you want a recipe that helps with weight loss, better fur, stamina, etc. Ollie does not. 

There’s not much difference in price between the two, but Ollie does offer more ways to cut down on costs than Spot and Tango. However, what they do have are their nutrient-complete recipes. In theory, you wouldn’t have to spend money on supplements if you feed your dog Ollie. If your dog responds well to Ollie it could save you a lot of money in that department.

Choose Ollie If…

You want more options when it comes to saving on costs like mixing dry food with wet food or purchasing partial portions. Even without these savings, however, prices can go as low as $4 per day plus free shipping. If their nutrient-complete recipes work well for your dog, your spending on vitamins and supplements will be greatly reduced, if not eliminated. Plus, there’s also the fact that Ollie donates frequently to pet welfare organizations.