• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Good Pup Life

Good Pup Life

Everything related to dogs

  • Safety
  • Grooming
  • Training
  • Health Care
    • Dog Wellbeing
  • Buying Guides
    • Best Wireless Dog Fence
    • Best GPS Dog Fence
    • Best Dog Nail Grinder
    • Best Dog DNA Test Reviews
    • Best Dog Leash Reviews
    • Best Dog Crate Reviews
    • Best Indestructible Dog Toys Reviews
    • Best Bark Collar Reviews
    • Best Dog GPS Tracker Reviews
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Freshpet vs Farmers Dog 2025 (Fresh Dog Food: Rolls or Custom Meals?)

Freshpet vs Farmer's Dog

Who is Freshpet for?

  • Smaller dogs. Considering the bags used, Freshpet may be small for larger dogs.
  • Dog owners that prefer locally sourced ingredients
  • Those concerned about safety as Freshpet does not use any questionable preservatives or additives
Freshpet vs Farmers Dog

Who is The Farmer’s Dog for?

  • Dogs with specific needs as the freshly made food is personalized to each dog’s unique attributes and health targets.
  • Dog owners who want to offer their pet purely fresh food made from wholesome ingredients without any fillers or additives.
  • Those looking for a dog food delivery service for their home, workplace, or any other location.
  • Dogs of every shape and size due to the diverse amount of meal plans.

Like many dog owners, I used to be so concerned with what my furry friends consume regularly. It was hard for me to continuously think of a tasty homemade fresh dog food recipe that satisfies all of its nutritional needs hence the need for a reliable dog food subscription that works for me and my pet. Platforms like Freshpet and The Farmer’s Dog were specifically created to solve this problem as they have teams that source, prepare and package the dog food. It is according to safety and nutritional pet food requirements. They also go the extra mile to consider the profile of various dogs. Dog owners can key in the attributes of their pets, such as age, weight, breed, activity levels, or even health issues. These characteristics form a profile that curates the best possible meal plans as per the targets you want for the dog. Dog food delivery service platforms like these are a more effective way of feeding your pet because you can shave weight or reduce the effect of any health issues, but which service is better for you? Read my detailed Freshpet vs Farmers Dog review.

Freshpet Features

Freshpet.

Pros

  • The platform has a great nutritional breakdown of the recipes.
  • There is local ingredient sourcing and efficient delivery to ensure the food retains freshness 
  • The dog food is packaged in convenient rolls which can be portioned effectively. 
  • Ingredients are made without preservatives and fillers to preserve nutrient quality.

Cons

  • The fresh pet food packaging would be practical for small dogs due to sizing and cost implications.

High-Quality Ingredients

When you compare Freshpet to traditional dry dog foods, it becomes apparent that it does not utilize any preservatives or questionable ingredients when making the recipes. The ingredients are also sourced locally, so there is less transportation required while ensuring the fresh aspect of the dog food is maintained. That being said, the meals have to be stored in a refrigerator when not being used due to the freshness of the ingredients.

Unboxing

Freshpet is usually sold in meat rolls which may not look appetizing to people, but it probably is for dogs. When you give your dog one of these rolls, markings are indicated in the packaging, illustrating eighth-pound portions. That allows you to cut the appropriate amount for your pooch each meal time. Freshpet usually recommends that you feed the dog at least one pound a day, meaning the dog would eat a full roll daily.

Pricing

The pricing for Freshpet food varies according to the recipe option you choose as it is assessed according to the rolls. A six-pound roll, for example, would cost $12. It also depends on the size and age of the dog. Say you have a one-year-old, 50-pound dog. It would mean feeding them about a pound of fresh meals every day, which would cost $2.2 daily.  

The Farmer’s Dog Features

The Farmer's Dog.

Pros

  • The meal plans can be adequately customized to fit your dog’s needs.
  • The Farmer’s dog uses high-quality human-grade ingredients 
  • The convenience of flexible subscription and efficient delivery to your doorstep 
  • It contains no preservatives or fillers.

Cons

  • The food is bulky, so it can occupy much space in the freezer.

Quality and Safety

The Farmer’s Dog takes care not to use any feed-grade ingredients for any of the recipes. All the food is made in approved environments, while the ingredients also meet the required standards for safety. The AAFCO statement is included as well in the breakdown of every recipe. In addition to being made by veterinary nutritionists, The Farmer’s Dog meals are crafted for a complete and balanced nutrition. To make fresh meals, The Farmer’s Dog uses healthy ingredients like green beans, sweet potatoes, and brown rice.

Ordering and Delivery

Fresh dog food delivery from The Farmer’s Dog is relatively straightforward. All you have to do is fill out a questionnaire to provide your dog’s attributes. The platform specialists then work to come up with an individualized meal plan. Individuals then get a confirmation on order and receive updated tracking concerning the package as they wait for it to arrive. Each package is frozen as well and proportioned with labels for each of the dogs.

Pricing

Your dog’s diet with The Farmer’s Dog may cost anywhere from $2 to $10 a day, depending on the dog’s size, as smaller pets incur a smaller cost. If you have a dog that weighs 50 pounds, with no health problems, and leads an active lifestyle, it may cost about $6.14 a day to feed them. That means it would cost $53.8 a week, which is expensive.

Overview of Each Product

Freshpet meals are made to provide dogs with the freshest possible meals each time. The roll packaging the food comes in is also convenient to use as it also comes with markings for portioning. Freshpet is also typically affordable, considering the costs of these rolls are cheaper when compared to the portioning of The Farmer’s Dog.

Freshpet.

Choose Freshpet if…

You want conveniently packaged high-quality dog food, which is also relatively affordable. It is also for smaller pets because the rolls may be impractical for larger dogs. It is also convenient as the ingredients are locally sourced, and the platform has an excellent tracking service for packages ordered by customers.

The Farmer’s Dog is also a high-quality dog food subscription platform that focuses on the quality and safety of the ingredients. This is, to an extent, the AAFCO statement is included on the labels for verification purposes. Like Freshpet, it does have a convenient packaging system, considering there is pre-portioning. They are also frozen to maintain the nutrient quality before these are served to the dog. Price-wise, The Farmer’s Dog is costly, so pet owners can use Topper plans for sustainability.

The Farmer's Dog.

Choose The Farmer’s Dog if…

You want high-quality food that serves dogs with different needs [1]. That is because of the diverse nature of the meal plans. The Farmer’s Dog also offers sophisticated customization and safety provisions for the food. It is slightly expensive compared to other dog food subscription options.

You are here: Home / Freshpet vs Farmers Dog 2025 (Fresh Dog Food: Rolls or Custom Meals?)

Primary Sidebar

Privacy Policy

Contact us

About us

Copyright © 2025 Good Pup Life.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Links and References