JustFoodForDogs is great for dog owners who:
- Can afford to spend more.
- Want their dog’s food to have superior taste and nutrition quality.
- Want thoroughly customizable recipes.
Ollie is great for dog owners who:
- Want more savings options.
- Would like dog food recipes that use novel ingredients to enrich their nutrient content.
- Want dog food that tastes great despite costing less.
Feeding my dog the best fresh dog food made from whole, human-grade ingredients is all well and good, but I might be of the persuasion that wholesome ingredients are only as good as the methods used to prepare them. Most of the best dog food delivery subscriptions will always find a way to make the production process cheaper, and hence that means processing in some form of another.
That’s not a worry with Just Food For Dogs, who prepare each meal to order in their special pet food kitchens. What results is food that preserves all of the nutrients of the whole ingredients used, and is downright restaurant-quality in terms of taste. However, this does mean that their products are not as affordable as many other brands’.
Enter Ollie dog food, a brand that doesn’t make any claims of having fancy kitchens, but assures customers of premium taste and nutrition quality nonetheless. Their food isn’t quite homemade, but is still fresh and intended to be nutrient-complete for dogs of all life stages—and is less expensive to boot.
Let’s see how these two brands stack up against each other in my Just Food For Dogs vs Ollie comparison review.
Just Food For Dogs Features
Pros
- Employs a large team of veterinarians and other animal and nutrition experts.
- Customization is done by consulting with their vet team, allowing for more flexibility..
- Has brick and mortar locations with open kitchens where you can order a la carte.
- Conducts year-long, completely humane feeding trials to ensure quality
Cons
- Less affordable than most.
- Portion sizes vary in size depending on the recipe.
Certified PantryFresh Offerings
Just Food For Dogs dog food delivery service also offers certified PantryFresh products along with their standard fresh food option. PantryFresh products stay completely fresh and wholesome for up to two years, no need for refrigeration.
Brick and Mortar Stores
Unlike virtually every other fresh dog food subscription service, Just Food For Dogs boasts several physical stores throughout the US with more to open in the future. These stores have open kitchens where people and their pets can watch the magic happen. This is great for pet parents to ensure that their fur babies’ food is being made with care, and it’d certainly be a spectacle for the pets as well.
One-on-One Consultations
Instead of a customization interface, Just Food For Dogs schedules consultations with a member of their veterinary team. This professional then takes a look at your pet to determine the best nutrition plan for them, as well as advise the owner on health guidelines to follow. Owners can then tell them about any allergies, food sensitivities, or health conditions they may have, and negotiate certain specifications they want for their recipes.
No Subscription Needed
Just Food For Dogs lets you order without a subscription as well, unlike most other dog food subscription services. This is perfect for pet owners who only want to be supplied with Just Food For Dogs at irregular intervals, to spice up their pets’ usual meals or as an occasional treat.
Expanding List of Partner Stores
The company is also partnering with a growing number of pet clinics and pet stores where customers can purchase a la carte meals or pick up their deliveries to save on delivery fees. This lets them reach a much wider client base even with only a handful of physical locations.
Ollie Features
Pros
- Uses nutritious ingredients such as spinach, sweet potatoes, and berries to flesh out recipes’ nutrient profiles.
- You can type in any type of food sensitivity or allergy your dog may have yourself, and they will adjust their recipes accordingly.
- Ollie’s kibble is oven-baked instead of dried, making it more wholesome.
- You can ask them for a half-and-half mix of fresh food and dry food to shave a decent amount off of your bill.
- You can also order in increments of 25 percent of your dog’s daily caloric requirement [1] to tailor how much you spend per week.
Cons
- Ollie does not offer special diets for weight loss, kidney troubles, etc.
- Although Ollie offers plenty of options to save on costs, it can still be expensive if you want the full experience.
Plenty of Savings Options
Ollie understands that the price of quality fresh dog foods can be quite steep for the average consumer. So they have several options to reduce costs, such as partial and mixed ordering. Shipping is also free.
Baked Dry Food
Unlike most commercially available kibble, Ollie’s dry dog food is oven-baked to preserve freshness and nutrient content.
Rich Nutrient Profiles
Ollie’s products are crafted with the intent to reduce the need for supplements, if not eliminate it entirely. Recipes are fully fleshed out with ingredients such as spinach, chia seeds cod liver oil, and blueberries. These superfoods supply your dog with a much more complete set of nutrients.
Appetite Enhancer
Thanks to their focus on taste and partial portion options, Ollie is also perfect for when you just want to make dog meals yummier. If your dog is losing interest in mealtimes, you can prevent them from losing weight by mixing some Ollie in their food.
Donates to Rescue Organizations
Ollie pet food service donates 1 percent of all revenues to shelters across the country. They also donate thousands of pounds of their dog food to those shelters each year.
Overview of Each Product
Just Food For Dogs’ products are focused on quality and convenience. This means that the price tag is heftier, but for many, this is well worth it. For their price, you get a team of vets who do one-on-one sessions with your pet to really get a detailed look into their physiology, and thus develop the perfect recipes for them. Pet chefs carefully cook every dish to these specifications. What you get is essentially a premium version of home-cooked dog food.
Choose Just Food For Dogs If…
You want gourmet-quality dishes and recipes that are meticulously crafted for your dog’s specific needs and physical characteristics. In terms of both taste and balanced nutrition, Just Food For Dogs is simply superior to Ollie. The only real disadvantage to it is the fact that it’s more expensive.
You can think of Ollie as a discount version of Just Food For Dogs, although without the one-on-one vet sessions and pet chefs cooking each meal to order. Their food is still made to be as nutritious as possible, as they want their meals to be nutrient-complete. Plus, you also have the option to purchase oven-baked dry food from them, which is healthier than usual kibble, but keeps just as well and is cheaper than most fresh foods.
Choose Ollie If…
You want more options when it comes to saving on costs like mixing dry food with wet food or purchasing partial portions. Even without these savings, however, prices can go as low as $4 per day plus free shipping. By comparison, Just Food For Dogs can cost you $6 – $8 per day on average. And even though Ollie costs less, dogs still find it delicious. You do lose out in terms of recipe customization, however.
