Sundays is great for dog owners who:
- Want dog food that can stay in storage for a long time without refrigeration.
- Want to see exactly what goes into the recipes.
- Would like to try what’s fast becoming the best kibble on the market.
Spot and Tango is great for dog owners who:
- Want finer recipe customization.
- Have dogs with special dietary needs.
- Think that a policy of reducing food waste is a big plus for dog food companies.
After 2 years of success with their proprietary “fresh dry” food UnKibble, Spot and Tango found new competition in the form of Sundays. Up until Sundays entered the picture in 2020, no one could quite compare with UnKibble, which gave customers a more affordable, more shelf-stable way to experience the best fresh dog food for their dogs. But with Sundays’ ever-rising popularity, it seems that UnKibble is in real danger of being dethroned, if it hasn’t been already. Let’s see how the odds stack up in my Sundays Dog Food vs Spot and Tango review and which could be the best dog food delivery service.
Sundays Dog Food Features
Pros
- Strives to be as nutrient-complete as possible using ingredients like beef heart, quinoa, and sunflower oil.
- Made more affordable by local sourcing, efficient production, and other methods.
- Stays fresh without refrigeration. Shelf stable for up to 2 years unopened.
- Expertly crafted and regularly updated recipes.
Cons
- Limited recipe choices. Only beef and chicken are available so far. No news yet as to whether they plan to expand on that.
- Only dry food is available. No fresh or wet offerings to speak of.
Air-Dried For Premium Taste and Texture
Sundays uses a slow air-drying process to give their kibble a satisfying crunch while preserving premium-quality taste and nutrient content. It’s also the reason why Sundays is so shelf-stable.
Rich Nutrient Profiles
Their all-natural nutrient mix is what puts Sundays a step above even the best premium kibble out there. Their recipes use ingredients like beef heart, ground bone, turmeric, and other natural foodstuffs that infuse their kibble with a wide range of nutrients, reducing or eliminating the need for supplements.
Regularly Updated Recipes
Sundays’ recipes are frequently updated by their veterinary nutritionist team, lead by co-founder Tory Waxman, VMD. These updates are based on the latest findings in which ingredients offer the best benefits for dogs. You can see what changes their recipes have undergone so far on their changelog.
Excellent Shelf-Stability
Before and after opening, Sundays is excellent at retaining freshness even without refrigeration. This lets you save on precious fridge space that fresh frozen dog food so often devours. Resealed bags stay fresh for up to 8 weeks, while unopened ones stay good for up to 2 years.
Competitive Pricing
The daily cost of feeding Sundays to an average-sized dog is estimated at only $4. Considering the quality of their kibble surpasses even that of Spot and Tango’s UnKibble, this is an excellent deal. However, Spot and Tango does offer more options to save than Sundays does.
Spot And Tango Features
Pros
- Offers a proprietary “fresh dry” kibble called UnKibble, which is much tastier and more wholesome than store-bought kibble.
- Offer topper plans to be mixed in with your everyday pet food for a lower cost.
- Uses plenty of fruits and vegetables to round out the nutrient content of their recipes.
- Subscription plans are easy to tweak to your liking on their website.
Cons
- Certain options need to be accessed through customer service, such as ordering both fresh dog food and UnKibble.
- Online reviews suggest that their customer service leaves a bit to be desired.
“Fresh Dry” Dog Food
Before Sundays, UnKibble was perhaps the only dry dog food on the market made using fresh and wholesome ingredients. It still retains its premium quality, offering fresh taste in an easy-to-serve and shelf-stable package. It’s superior to conventional kibble, arguably even Ollie’s oven-baked kibble. However, it’s still no substitute to actual fresh food.
Fairly Priced
Spot and Tango is one of the few dog food brands right in the sweet spot when it comes to pricing, at around $6 to $7 for a medium-sized dog. UnKibble, on the other hand, starts at $4.70. If you take out a topper plan, those rates can get cut by around half, so consider that if you want a cheaper option.
Numerous Health Considerations
Their customization interface has a wide range of dietary specifications to choose from. These include everything from basic allergies and dental issues to serious health problems such as diabetes and digestive disorders. If you don’t find what you’re looking for on their list, you can specify what you want them to account for in their recipes by typing it in the box provided. You can also state whether you want the recipes to be gluten-free.
Wide Range of Ingredients
Since they take a lot more dietary needs into consideration, Spot and Tango draws from a bigger selection of ingredients to make healthy dog food. These include everything from blueberries to apple cider, which you don’t often see in dog food. Since they’re much less limited in terms of ingredient choice, there’s a better chance of your dog receiving the nutrition they need [1].
Upcycles “Ugly Produce” and Other Food Waste
Spot and Tango gets a lot of sustainability points by practicing upcycling, which in the context of food is the repurposing of perfectly good food items that were rejected because they don’t meet superficial standards. This includes “ugly produce”, which are vegetables that have deformities that make consumers avoid them. Practicing upcycling helps out the worldwide food supply by using food that would’ve otherwise gone to waste.
Overview of Each Product
Sundays only offer dry food. This can be a dealbreaker if your dog doesn’t like kibble or you’d like to get a mix of fresh and dry. However even picky dogs may find a renewed appreciation for dry dog food because of Sundays’ high quality fresh ingredients. Sundays comes in decently sized, wafer-shaped pieces. Some dogs may dislike this shape, but the size can make it more satisfying to chew on.
They’re very transparent about ingredient info, and you can see the entire update history of their recipes in the changelog. There’s also a great feature on their website that lets you compare their products’ nutrient profiles against over 3,000 dog food products.
Choose Sundays If…
You want easy-to-serve, nutrient-complete kibble that keeps much better in storage than that of other brands’. You’re more limited in terms of protein choice, but as long as your dog isn’t picky or allergic, this shouldn’t be a problem.
Spot and Tango’s UnKibble is much more rounded out and has an arguably better texture than Sundays. Taste-wise, it’s likely that the average dog will clean out a bowl full of UnKibble as thoroughly as a bowl full of Sundays, but there are reports that some dogs prefer the taste of Sundays to UnKibble.
However, Spot and Tango offers much more customization to tweak UnKibble and their fresh food option to your dog’s taste preferences, as well as special dietary needs.
Choose Spot and Tango If…
You want better recipe customization. Sundays only has a minimal amount of this, and not to mention only two choices of protein. Spot and Tango lets you specify which health conditions and wellness targets you want to hit, and they’ll do the rest.
You may also want the choice between fresh food and dry food, or a mix between the two. This is another big edge Spot and Tango has over Sundays. It may turn out that Sundays can beat UnKibble, but Spot and Tango can be the more affordable choice with their topper plans and mixing UnKibble with fresh meals.
